Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Support
  • MyRoute-app
Collapse
Brand Logo

MRA Community Forum

  1. Home
  2. The MyRoute-app
  3. [App] Problems, Bugs and other Issues
  4. Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom

Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved [App] Problems, Bugs and other Issues
36 Posts 9 Posters 2.0k Views 6 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Peter Schieferundefined Peter Schiefer

    @Afterforever666

    Hello Afterforever,

    I am with you regard the new visibility of MRA on a CarPlay screen or on a tablett campared to other Apps like Sygic, TOMTOM, Google. Also the verbal instructions are in German language are the best. Apple maps are also not bad in visibility and with some less concerns instructions. A hightlight of A-Maps are the traffic lights in the map in cities a big advantage for counting the crossings.
    But back to MRA, MRA next use HERE maps and in average the are not worse than competitors. Regard speed limits, they all have problems with actuallity.
    Regard live traffic, MRAnext has no live traffic. Not yet.
    You can select traffic info on the webplaner, but Next use only at start and calculation knowing traffic infos from HERE.

    Nick Carthewundefined Online
    Nick Carthewundefined Online
    Nick Carthew
    RouteXperts Instructor
    wrote on last edited by
    #9

    @Peter-Schiefer said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

    Regard live traffic, MRAnext has no live traffic. Not yet.
    You can select traffic info on the webplaner, but Next use only at start and calculation knowing traffic infos from HERE.

    @Peter-Schiefer If you are unsure of an answer, please do not reply with an incorrect answer.

    Always willing to help if I can.
    Triumph Tiger 1200 XRT called Tina.
    MRA Navigation Next and SilverFox B8J bar buttons.
    Quadlock wireless mount for IPhone 11.
    Cardo Scala Packtalk Bold.
    TomTom Rider 500. (In the cupboard now)

    1 Reply Last reply
    2
    • Nick Carthewundefined Nick Carthew

      @Afterforever666 @GT-JWR There is a setting in Functional Traffic aware route calculation, I do not use this myself as: a. I ride a motorcycle and I can normally slip through any traffic and: b. I live in rural Devon where the likelihood of being held up by traffic is minimal, I'm more likely to be held up by a farmer moving a flock sheep and as far as I know, slow moving sheep are not registered! 😊
      I would imagine that with a title like Traffic aware route calculation, it will guide you by any major traffic problems. Maybe someone on the forum that uses this setting can enlighten us to how it works.

      GT JWRundefined Offline
      GT JWRundefined Offline
      GT JWR
      wrote on last edited by
      #10

      @Nick-Carthew haha - worst thing I have, other than wildlife (deer) appearing at the most inopportune time, is going through free cattle range areas!

      I have that function set to on, however, if it is supposed to work as I menitoned, it does not seem to. 🤷

      1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • Peter Schieferundefined Peter Schiefer

        @Afterforever666

        so different are opinions.
        My main object of MRA is the planer on the Web. So easy to use, a lot of layouts including the Michelin map with the green marker alongside for beautiful country roads, a button to change to street view wher you want to get an impression of for sample street width, a parking spot, a destination. I use MRA planer since 4 years, substitute Basecamp, and since last year the routing App Next. Nextis on continuous improvement, really not perfect yet. I have also concerns here.

        Sygic can not work with tranfered GPX files from MRA planer. The route is correct, but if you have included fix Waypoints POIs may a position D Restaurant stop at „Schnitzelpfanne“ than on Sygic, you get not verbal advices no Map info of this POIs.

        I checked Osmand too. not only one time. At each new YT vid of an „influencer“ for Osmand i tried it again, I never come to a satisfying result in the usabilty. Hide and seek was my impression. May it is a result of usabilty with Apple and it is easier on an Android system.

        An my personal opinion regard to live travic after ten years on the road by my job in Europe and Germany and on holiday trips.
        For me the utilise is overrated. On special days like season weekends you have problems everywhere and you need a tablett in addition to create own routes far away from the more parallel deviations recommended. And on Country roads in the nowhere you don‘t need it.
        Three weeks ago we where in Libourne close to Bordeaux east side and we want to drive to Arcachon extra decide not on the weekend. The highway circle surround BX was full of trucks and other traficc to Spain at the exit to arcachon is only on street to this little city. For the last 10 Kilometer 1 h on G-Maps. No chance. We turned and drove to another location 30 km south from Arcachon. Not empty but not so overcrowded.

        Afterforever666undefined Offline
        Afterforever666undefined Offline
        Afterforever666
        wrote on last edited by
        #11

        @Peter-Schiefer said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

        @Afterforever666

        so different are opinions....

        Indeed Peter, many different opinions. We all have different purposes for which we use these planning and navigation apps.
        MRA shows off with offering somekind of end to end toolset (from planning to navigation). As i drive a camper (for which planning is a plus) and a car and a motorcycle, i wanted to spend my money on the whole suite. Now, in end to end the chain is only as strong as the weakest shackle. The whole point of buying the full licence lifetime was to be able to stay in the same ecosystem for all my travelling and driving. I'm really happy with the planning part, but navigation needs some extra love. I mentioned before that i'm in favor of high configurability as opposed to trying a one size fits all app. E.g. Osmand+ is highly configurable, but has become messy and complicated. They should introduce something like "user profiles" (basic, advanced, expert) and progressively open more settings depending on selected profile. Waze on the other hand is more of one size fits all but as such has limitations for many users. Somewhere in between is a sweet spot.
        I think MRA have some great UI designers who can pull it off : high flexibility while keeping user-friendlyness and not having too steep learning curve.

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • Nick Carthewundefined Nick Carthew

          @Afterforever666 @GT-JWR There is a setting in Functional Traffic aware route calculation, I do not use this myself as: a. I ride a motorcycle and I can normally slip through any traffic and: b. I live in rural Devon where the likelihood of being held up by traffic is minimal, I'm more likely to be held up by a farmer moving a flock sheep and as far as I know, slow moving sheep are not registered! 😊
          I would imagine that with a title like Traffic aware route calculation, it will guide you by any major traffic problems. Maybe someone on the forum that uses this setting can enlighten us to how it works.

          Afterforever666undefined Offline
          Afterforever666undefined Offline
          Afterforever666
          wrote on last edited by
          #12

          @Nick-Carthew said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

          @Afterforever666 @GT-JWR
          I would imagine that with a title like Traffic aware route calculation, it will guide you by any major traffic problems. Maybe someone on the forum that uses this setting can enlighten us to how it works.

          I've had that setting on all the time, just double checked. Didn't do much apparently. Wonder how it would have been with the setting off...

          Nick Carthewundefined 1 Reply Last reply
          1
          • Nick Carthewundefined Nick Carthew

            @Afterforever666 There is live traffic if you navigate online. I don’t know why @Peter-Schiefer was telling you there isn’t! The yellow/orange means traffic is building up, the red indicates stationary traffic.

            6adb7c67-a13c-4b3d-802f-c6f5530ecbe5-image.png

            Peter Schieferundefined Offline
            Peter Schieferundefined Offline
            Peter Schiefer
            wrote on last edited by Peter Schiefer
            #13

            @Nick-Carthew

            Nick as far as I know and have understand MRA description up to now at start of the route traffic will be recognized and calculated. If there is a big issue later while driving on your route, which results in an additional not acceptable time frame (more then ten minutes) you will not get an new Info, means no live traffic. This was my content.

            By the way even google will not change or give a reccommendation far a change for cues of few minutes, but you see at each traffic light a red line for the few cars waiting there. Nonsens.

            Crazy was maybe is Sygic, which tells you every few minutes on your route „You can save 3 Minutes or 5 Minutes on your route. will you accept the proposal.“
            This is also nonsens, first due tue the time may lost and second the cue is perhaps on your 150 km trip at position 80 km, means you need an hour to reach this point and meanwhile the cue is over and not present when you be there.

            These annoying permanen proposal for route correction is one of the reasons why I not be a fan Sygic.

            Peter

            Nick Carthewundefined 1 Reply Last reply
            -1
            • Peter Schieferundefined Peter Schiefer

              @Nick-Carthew

              Nick as far as I know and have understand MRA description up to now at start of the route traffic will be recognized and calculated. If there is a big issue later while driving on your route, which results in an additional not acceptable time frame (more then ten minutes) you will not get an new Info, means no live traffic. This was my content.

              By the way even google will not change or give a reccommendation far a change for cues of few minutes, but you see at each traffic light a red line for the few cars waiting there. Nonsens.

              Crazy was maybe is Sygic, which tells you every few minutes on your route „You can save 3 Minutes or 5 Minutes on your route. will you accept the proposal.“
              This is also nonsens, first due tue the time may lost and second the cue is perhaps on your 150 km trip at position 80 km, means you need an hour to reach this point and meanwhile the cue is over and not present when you be there.

              These annoying permanen proposal for route correction is one of the reasons why I not be a fan Sygic.

              Nick Carthewundefined Online
              Nick Carthewundefined Online
              Nick Carthew
              RouteXperts Instructor
              wrote on last edited by
              #14

              @Peter-Schiefer The coloured lines that are shown on the map for traffic do not control how the route is drawn, they are merely a visual indicator. So they are live.

              Always willing to help if I can.
              Triumph Tiger 1200 XRT called Tina.
              MRA Navigation Next and SilverFox B8J bar buttons.
              Quadlock wireless mount for IPhone 11.
              Cardo Scala Packtalk Bold.
              TomTom Rider 500. (In the cupboard now)

              1 Reply Last reply
              1
              • Afterforever666undefined Afterforever666

                @Nick-Carthew said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

                @Afterforever666 @GT-JWR
                I would imagine that with a title like Traffic aware route calculation, it will guide you by any major traffic problems. Maybe someone on the forum that uses this setting can enlighten us to how it works.

                I've had that setting on all the time, just double checked. Didn't do much apparently. Wonder how it would have been with the setting off...

                Nick Carthewundefined Online
                Nick Carthewundefined Online
                Nick Carthew
                RouteXperts Instructor
                wrote on last edited by
                #15

                @Afterforever666 Of course, this setting would only have an effect if you are navigating online. I'm not sure if you were or not.

                Always willing to help if I can.
                Triumph Tiger 1200 XRT called Tina.
                MRA Navigation Next and SilverFox B8J bar buttons.
                Quadlock wireless mount for IPhone 11.
                Cardo Scala Packtalk Bold.
                TomTom Rider 500. (In the cupboard now)

                1 Reply Last reply
                0
                • Afterforever666undefined Afterforever666

                  @Peter-Schiefer said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

                  @Afterforever666

                  Hello Afterforever,

                  I am with you regard the new visibility of MRA on a CarPlay screen or on a tablett campared to other Apps like Sygic, TOMTOM, Google. Also the verbal instructions are in German language are the best. Apple maps are also not bad in visibility and with some less concerns instructions. A hightlight of A-Maps are the traffic lights in the map in cities a big advantage for counting the crossings.
                  But back to MRA, MRA next use HERE maps and in average the are not worse than competitors. Regard speed limits, they all have problems with actuallity.
                  Regard live traffic, MRAnext has no live traffic. Not yet.
                  You can select traffic info on the webplaner, but Next use only at start and calculation knowing traffic infos from HERE.

                  Hi Peter,

                  Thanks for some thoughts! I wasn't aware there was no live traffic in MRA. If I had not overlooked that, i wouldn't even have spent money on it. I hope that whenever they provide this capability, i won't have to pay extra. For now, i will switch to Sygic or OSMAnd+ as this is a dealbreaker for me.
                  For the Speed Limits : i know no map has them completely right, but the HERE map is by far the worst of all.

                  Con Hennekensundefined Offline
                  Con Hennekensundefined Offline
                  Con Hennekens
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #16

                  @Afterforever666 said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

                  I wasn't aware there was no live traffic in MRA.

                  Yes there is live traffic in MRA. It just does not recalculate routes dynamically using traffic info. Given the projects target on scenic routes, that is a plausible choice from the devs. Since more and more people are using MRA for purposes besides the original target, MRA has already acknowledged that dynamic traffic recalculation is in their wishlist. So all in due time 😉

                  I am just an enthusiastic MRA user, and hope you will be one too!

                  Most motorcycle problems are caused by the nut that connects the handlebar to the saddle.

                  Streetpilot 2610 / Zumo 660 / Zumo 395 / CAT S52 + MRA app

                  Peter Schieferundefined 1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • Con Hennekensundefined Con Hennekens

                    @Afterforever666 said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

                    I wasn't aware there was no live traffic in MRA.

                    Yes there is live traffic in MRA. It just does not recalculate routes dynamically using traffic info. Given the projects target on scenic routes, that is a plausible choice from the devs. Since more and more people are using MRA for purposes besides the original target, MRA has already acknowledged that dynamic traffic recalculation is in their wishlist. So all in due time 😉

                    Peter Schieferundefined Offline
                    Peter Schieferundefined Offline
                    Peter Schiefer
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #17

                    @Con-Hennekens

                    regard Live traffic, sorry Con
                    what you comment is playing with words

                    When you google the term „Live Traffic“ the common answer is:

                    Mit Live Traffic Information wird Ihre Route automatisch anhand von Echtzeit Verkehrsinformationen angepasst und optimiert.

                    With Live Traffic Information, your route is automatically adjusted and optimised based on real-time traffic information.

                    The Systems with Live traffic like Garmin, TT, Car-included installation“ allows you to select „always use best route“ or „confirm proposal when new information popped up“

                    This is not in MRA next actually, even when the map presents actual cues, jams everywhere in in the world.

                    Peter

                    Con Hennekensundefined 1 Reply Last reply
                    -1
                    • Peter Schieferundefined Peter Schiefer

                      @Con-Hennekens

                      regard Live traffic, sorry Con
                      what you comment is playing with words

                      When you google the term „Live Traffic“ the common answer is:

                      Mit Live Traffic Information wird Ihre Route automatisch anhand von Echtzeit Verkehrsinformationen angepasst und optimiert.

                      With Live Traffic Information, your route is automatically adjusted and optimised based on real-time traffic information.

                      The Systems with Live traffic like Garmin, TT, Car-included installation“ allows you to select „always use best route“ or „confirm proposal when new information popped up“

                      This is not in MRA next actually, even when the map presents actual cues, jams everywhere in in the world.

                      Con Hennekensundefined Offline
                      Con Hennekensundefined Offline
                      Con Hennekens
                      wrote on last edited by Con Hennekens
                      #18

                      @Peter-Schiefer, if I am playing with words, you are too. I am sure I can find some internet link to back me up, but I am not starting that 😉 . Most important is that dynamic route calculation is on the devs minds. All in due time.

                      I am just an enthusiastic MRA user, and hope you will be one too!

                      Most motorcycle problems are caused by the nut that connects the handlebar to the saddle.

                      Streetpilot 2610 / Zumo 660 / Zumo 395 / CAT S52 + MRA app

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • Afterforever666undefined Afterforever666

                        I used the myrouteapp on my android head unit in my campervan (so NOT via android auto) for all travelling of a 14 day holiday in UK. Drove a total of 2400km, of which I estimate only 30% was on highways. All other travelling was on secondary roads.
                        Since my android device has the capability of split-screen, I always used another navigation app next to myrouteapp. Magic Earth, Waze, Google Maps, Sygic or OsmAnd+.
                        Here are my observations :
                        The Good :

                        • Internet connection : I had data roaming on all the time and connectivity was maintained all the time by the app.
                        • The visualisation of the route on the display is by far the best on the myrouteapp. The zooming, and tilting using the default values is spot on. All other navigation apps are doing a worse job in my opinion (I know this is subjective, but wanted to share my opinion).
                        • There have literally been NO occasions that the destination I wanted to enter was not present in the map. All POI's, addresses, camperplaces were present.
                        • When in the Park4Night app, clicking "itinary" and opening MyRouteApp works flawlessly.
                        • The app didn't crash a single time!
                        • The use of via-points and way-points planned upfront worked perfect. Had no issues at all.

                        The Bad :

                        • Speed Restrictions are incorrect about 90% of the time. They are completely useless. After my return I read somewhere that this may be caused by using the Camper profile. Either way, it was bad.
                        • Configurability of Units : I found it frustrating that I could not keep distances on the screen in metric and have speeds in imperial. The "Metric" or "Imperial" setting applies both to distances and speeds. Some of the other navigations apps I used in parallel do allow this and that is a big plus.
                        • Traffic information : has been very unreliable. On many occasions myrouteapp didn't give any warnings about traffic jams or suggest other routes. Waze, Magic Earth and Sygic did a great job and be avoided some heavy traffic thanks to these apps.
                        • Roadworks : the map used for navigation has some major flaws. While I understand that local road changes can be hard to keep up with for the map provider, I think it's unacceptable that motorways under construction or that are blocked (for long periods, as indicated on the signs) are not represented well in the map. The side effect is of course that when the app then sees you're off route (where you have no choice because of deviation) it will continuously try to get you back on these same closed roads). Waze and Google Maps have been perfect in this respect.
                        • The popping up of the same ridiculous dialog that needs to be confirmed on every route planning is driving me nuts. Especially because pushing confirm doesn't work always, I need to push the button a few times before the dialog closes. No other navigation app does it this way. You need to agree on the liability statement once at install time, or perhaps when the app is started, but not on EVERY single route.

                        These are the things I remember. If more comes to mind I will add them.
                        I hope MyRouteApp team does something with this info. You may have fantastic routeplanner apps and trainings on how to use it, if the navigation or execution of the plan is flawed the circle is not closed. Please listen to your userbase.

                        Corjan Meijerinkundefined Offline
                        Corjan Meijerinkundefined Offline
                        Corjan Meijerink
                        administrator
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #19

                        @Afterforever666 Thanks for the very elaborate feedback! 😃
                        We do really tend to listen to our users.

                        The visualisation of the route on the display is by far the best on the myrouteapp. The zooming, and tilting using the default values is spot on. All other navigation apps are doing a worse job in my opinion (I know this is subjective, but wanted to share my opinion).

                        Happy to read that! I totally agree because I configured it 😉
                        It is indeed very subjective.

                        • Speed restrictions will be improved for motorhomes in the next update!
                        • Units can now be set in the app directly (for the app). Website is indeed a separate configuration (by design). You might want to plan in units you are familiar with but drive using the local units as these match the signs.
                        • Traffic information is something we want to improve! It's there, but not fully optimised. Root cause is that mainly our users drive their routes exactly as planned regardless of any delays.
                        • Roadworks, same as above.
                        • I'll change this ❤

                        Cheers!

                        GT JWRundefined Peter Schieferundefined 2 Replies Last reply
                        0
                        • Corjan Meijerinkundefined Corjan Meijerink

                          @Afterforever666 Thanks for the very elaborate feedback! 😃
                          We do really tend to listen to our users.

                          The visualisation of the route on the display is by far the best on the myrouteapp. The zooming, and tilting using the default values is spot on. All other navigation apps are doing a worse job in my opinion (I know this is subjective, but wanted to share my opinion).

                          Happy to read that! I totally agree because I configured it 😉
                          It is indeed very subjective.

                          • Speed restrictions will be improved for motorhomes in the next update!
                          • Units can now be set in the app directly (for the app). Website is indeed a separate configuration (by design). You might want to plan in units you are familiar with but drive using the local units as these match the signs.
                          • Traffic information is something we want to improve! It's there, but not fully optimised. Root cause is that mainly our users drive their routes exactly as planned regardless of any delays.
                          • Roadworks, same as above.
                          • I'll change this ❤

                          Cheers!

                          GT JWRundefined Offline
                          GT JWRundefined Offline
                          GT JWR
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #20

                          @Corjan-Meijerink said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

                          Traffic information is something we want to improve! It's there, but not fully optimised. Root cause is that mainly our users drive their routes exactly as planned regardless of any delays.

                          That seems to be more related to the nav app's ability to indicate/warn of upcoming traffic info as well as the app's inability to provide suggested alternate routes (as Google/Apple maps do, for example) in such situations.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • Corjan Meijerinkundefined Corjan Meijerink

                            @Afterforever666 Thanks for the very elaborate feedback! 😃
                            We do really tend to listen to our users.

                            The visualisation of the route on the display is by far the best on the myrouteapp. The zooming, and tilting using the default values is spot on. All other navigation apps are doing a worse job in my opinion (I know this is subjective, but wanted to share my opinion).

                            Happy to read that! I totally agree because I configured it 😉
                            It is indeed very subjective.

                            • Speed restrictions will be improved for motorhomes in the next update!
                            • Units can now be set in the app directly (for the app). Website is indeed a separate configuration (by design). You might want to plan in units you are familiar with but drive using the local units as these match the signs.
                            • Traffic information is something we want to improve! It's there, but not fully optimised. Root cause is that mainly our users drive their routes exactly as planned regardless of any delays.
                            • Roadworks, same as above.
                            • I'll change this ❤

                            Cheers!

                            Peter Schieferundefined Offline
                            Peter Schieferundefined Offline
                            Peter Schiefer
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #21

                            @Corjan-Meijerink

                            I performalso extended testing and report last time increasing problems with the announcement of shaping and waypoints.
                            May my test is hard on a 9 km trip but I found similar problems sometimes few weeks ago on my holidays in France.
                            The anouncements get in conflict when they are close to navigation instructions or close together
                            .
                            Youtuber everyday Roadster tested several Apps which works with Carplay (not MRA up to now, but I request him to do so) He was satisfied with scenic and so I bought a years description offer to compare it with MRA.
                            Big big advantages on the same route. A counter presenst all WPs
                            For shaping points no information either sound nor text but you see on the map the number 2 in a circle for the first one because Start is WP 1
                            A Viapoint will be announced with his text you create has his own number 1over3 in a droparrow on the map and is shown on the left upper main textbox on carplay with the remaining distance interuppted by routing instructions when necessary. You got repeating annoncement like Garmin do.
                            A quite clear and easy desing on CP.
                            Why is this not possible for MRA.
                            By the way there is an announcement for scenix 4 starts on 1. October.
                            Scenic leave HERE, because of the concerns regard colors ( like on MRA) and promise new options, like streetview integration
                            Let see what is better.
                            Up to now the planer on the Web is better with the several map overlays. MRA next is for me actually not reliable at several situations.

                            Peter

                            Dae 0undefined 1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • Peter Schieferundefined Peter Schiefer

                              @Corjan-Meijerink

                              I performalso extended testing and report last time increasing problems with the announcement of shaping and waypoints.
                              May my test is hard on a 9 km trip but I found similar problems sometimes few weeks ago on my holidays in France.
                              The anouncements get in conflict when they are close to navigation instructions or close together
                              .
                              Youtuber everyday Roadster tested several Apps which works with Carplay (not MRA up to now, but I request him to do so) He was satisfied with scenic and so I bought a years description offer to compare it with MRA.
                              Big big advantages on the same route. A counter presenst all WPs
                              For shaping points no information either sound nor text but you see on the map the number 2 in a circle for the first one because Start is WP 1
                              A Viapoint will be announced with his text you create has his own number 1over3 in a droparrow on the map and is shown on the left upper main textbox on carplay with the remaining distance interuppted by routing instructions when necessary. You got repeating annoncement like Garmin do.
                              A quite clear and easy desing on CP.
                              Why is this not possible for MRA.
                              By the way there is an announcement for scenix 4 starts on 1. October.
                              Scenic leave HERE, because of the concerns regard colors ( like on MRA) and promise new options, like streetview integration
                              Let see what is better.
                              Up to now the planer on the Web is better with the several map overlays. MRA next is for me actually not reliable at several situations.

                              Dae 0undefined Offline
                              Dae 0undefined Offline
                              Dae 0
                              wrote on last edited by Dae 0
                              #22

                              @Peter-Schiefer

                              Your statement about Scenic leaving HERE because of colours is incorrect. Scenic has had the ability to completely customise all colours with HERE maps for over a year.

                              They’ve moved to OSM due to HERE having performance issues, many routing issues and the fact that HERE don’t seem to care or be responsive to smaller developers.

                              I’m on the beta for Scenic 4 and have constant contact with the developer.

                              This is their explanation from their blog:-

                              We want the best for our users and that means empowering them with accurate, detailed maps, reliable routing options, and avoiding unwanted surprises. Around three years ago, Scenic switched to HERE maps, which served our adventurous community well. However, after two years of excellent service, HERE released a new mapping framework with changes to map styles and other elements that negatively impacted the community.

                              Since the switch, you’ve consistently reported a lack of map detail, counterintuitive route suggestions, and unexpected route alterations.

                              We’ve heard your concerns and appealed to HERE for feature request changes to address these challenges, specifically for motorcyclists and our other adventurers. But HERE’s focus has shifted to logistics and big automotive clients, and the needs of our close community were either not prioritized or were denied altogether.
                              We have now found a map partner that can answer each of these concerns as well as offer new features that will uniquely improve your Scenic experience, giving you more freedom to adventure your way.

                              Peter Schieferundefined Corjan Meijerinkundefined 2 Replies Last reply
                              2
                              • Dae 0undefined Dae 0

                                @Peter-Schiefer

                                Your statement about Scenic leaving HERE because of colours is incorrect. Scenic has had the ability to completely customise all colours with HERE maps for over a year.

                                They’ve moved to OSM due to HERE having performance issues, many routing issues and the fact that HERE don’t seem to care or be responsive to smaller developers.

                                I’m on the beta for Scenic 4 and have constant contact with the developer.

                                This is their explanation from their blog:-

                                We want the best for our users and that means empowering them with accurate, detailed maps, reliable routing options, and avoiding unwanted surprises. Around three years ago, Scenic switched to HERE maps, which served our adventurous community well. However, after two years of excellent service, HERE released a new mapping framework with changes to map styles and other elements that negatively impacted the community.

                                Since the switch, you’ve consistently reported a lack of map detail, counterintuitive route suggestions, and unexpected route alterations.

                                We’ve heard your concerns and appealed to HERE for feature request changes to address these challenges, specifically for motorcyclists and our other adventurers. But HERE’s focus has shifted to logistics and big automotive clients, and the needs of our close community were either not prioritized or were denied altogether.
                                We have now found a map partner that can answer each of these concerns as well as offer new features that will uniquely improve your Scenic experience, giving you more freedom to adventure your way.

                                Peter Schieferundefined Offline
                                Peter Schieferundefined Offline
                                Peter Schiefer
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #23

                                @Dae-0

                                I am just new in Scenic and I find the color adjustments and do some test with planning.
                                The handling with Waypoints ist just quite clearer.
                                Shapingpoints at Scenic these are Via points, which is in my point of view correct, are only bullets on the route with a number (assumed internally use only the Geocoordinates for route calculation in conjunction with the numbers in sequence) Viapoints in scenic called Stop poibt could named as you like and are announced as interim target (Milestone) 3 Times with remaining distance like Garmin do this. Text is on the screen. What MRA is doing with SPs and VPs is an overkill, which when they close together or near route advices which happen in cities also very quick get in trouble.
                                There are a lot of advantages with MRA especially currently with the Webplaner and I like it, but on MRA next the different handling of SPs and VPs in announcements by distances 700 m for SPs, which van be disabled and 2 Kilometers only one time for an interim Target Viapoint is for me in a car or with the limited View of infos on CarPlay not satisfying.
                                By the way, Scenic presents the text of Viapoints, called there Stop points in the main Text box of Carplay too.

                                Let see what Scenic additionally may do better next week with version 4.
                                May for my requests it should be better tool in the routing mode.

                                You know:The better ones is the enemy of the good ones.

                                Peter

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • Dae 0undefined Dae 0

                                  @Peter-Schiefer

                                  Your statement about Scenic leaving HERE because of colours is incorrect. Scenic has had the ability to completely customise all colours with HERE maps for over a year.

                                  They’ve moved to OSM due to HERE having performance issues, many routing issues and the fact that HERE don’t seem to care or be responsive to smaller developers.

                                  I’m on the beta for Scenic 4 and have constant contact with the developer.

                                  This is their explanation from their blog:-

                                  We want the best for our users and that means empowering them with accurate, detailed maps, reliable routing options, and avoiding unwanted surprises. Around three years ago, Scenic switched to HERE maps, which served our adventurous community well. However, after two years of excellent service, HERE released a new mapping framework with changes to map styles and other elements that negatively impacted the community.

                                  Since the switch, you’ve consistently reported a lack of map detail, counterintuitive route suggestions, and unexpected route alterations.

                                  We’ve heard your concerns and appealed to HERE for feature request changes to address these challenges, specifically for motorcyclists and our other adventurers. But HERE’s focus has shifted to logistics and big automotive clients, and the needs of our close community were either not prioritized or were denied altogether.
                                  We have now found a map partner that can answer each of these concerns as well as offer new features that will uniquely improve your Scenic experience, giving you more freedom to adventure your way.

                                  Corjan Meijerinkundefined Offline
                                  Corjan Meijerinkundefined Offline
                                  Corjan Meijerink
                                  administrator
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #24

                                  @Dae-0 said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

                                  They’ve moved to OSM due to HERE having performance issues, many routing issues and the fact that HERE don’t seem to care or be responsive to smaller developers.

                                  Performance issues, yes sometimes. Battery usage is a big issue but they are now actively working on improvements and I've seen some promising results!

                                  Routing issues? Never to be honest. We as MRA haven't always implemented stuff in the best way possible. Lack of correct information? Definitely sometimes but that would be worse with OSM.

                                  Caring about smaller developers? Not always as much as I would like but cannot really blame them for that. Switching to open sourced alternative means nobody cares as you need to care for yourself / hope some random community members do that.


                                  Generally I am a massive fan of OSM and Graphhopper routing. They do not however provide any development platform for both iOS / Android and definitely not a singular cross-platform enabler.
                                  So there is a lot of nuance to their post that can be added.

                                  Dae 0undefined Vincent Currenundefined 2 Replies Last reply
                                  1
                                  • Corjan Meijerinkundefined Corjan Meijerink

                                    @Dae-0 said in Overview of extended testing (goods and bads) done in United Kingdom:

                                    They’ve moved to OSM due to HERE having performance issues, many routing issues and the fact that HERE don’t seem to care or be responsive to smaller developers.

                                    Performance issues, yes sometimes. Battery usage is a big issue but they are now actively working on improvements and I've seen some promising results!

                                    Routing issues? Never to be honest. We as MRA haven't always implemented stuff in the best way possible. Lack of correct information? Definitely sometimes but that would be worse with OSM.

                                    Caring about smaller developers? Not always as much as I would like but cannot really blame them for that. Switching to open sourced alternative means nobody cares as you need to care for yourself / hope some random community members do that.


                                    Generally I am a massive fan of OSM and Graphhopper routing. They do not however provide any development platform for both iOS / Android and definitely not a singular cross-platform enabler.
                                    So there is a lot of nuance to their post that can be added.

                                    Dae 0undefined Offline
                                    Dae 0undefined Offline
                                    Dae 0
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #25

                                    @Corjan-Meijerink

                                    Absolutely. I was just pointing out the real reason that they’ve left HERE and correcting Peter’s assertion that it’s due to colours.

                                    I’m not loyal to a particular product or developer - I simply use the one that’s best for my needs and will honestly tell people if asked.

                                    I frequently mention Scenic on here as I prefer it over MRA for navigation. It meets my needs more than MRA. However, I often mention MRA on the Scenic forum, often with the claim that it’s light years ahead of Scenic for planning. It’s about balance and suitability. I see the MRA/Scenic combo as like having 2 dedicated tools in my toolbox, rather than a Swiss Army knife.

                                    Corjan Meijerinkundefined Peter Schieferundefined Con Hennekensundefined 3 Replies Last reply
                                    1
                                    • Dae 0undefined Dae 0

                                      @Corjan-Meijerink

                                      Absolutely. I was just pointing out the real reason that they’ve left HERE and correcting Peter’s assertion that it’s due to colours.

                                      I’m not loyal to a particular product or developer - I simply use the one that’s best for my needs and will honestly tell people if asked.

                                      I frequently mention Scenic on here as I prefer it over MRA for navigation. It meets my needs more than MRA. However, I often mention MRA on the Scenic forum, often with the claim that it’s light years ahead of Scenic for planning. It’s about balance and suitability. I see the MRA/Scenic combo as like having 2 dedicated tools in my toolbox, rather than a Swiss Army knife.

                                      Corjan Meijerinkundefined Offline
                                      Corjan Meijerinkundefined Offline
                                      Corjan Meijerink
                                      administrator
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #26

                                      @Dae-0 Appreciated! 🙂

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      0
                                      • Dae 0undefined Dae 0

                                        @Corjan-Meijerink

                                        Absolutely. I was just pointing out the real reason that they’ve left HERE and correcting Peter’s assertion that it’s due to colours.

                                        I’m not loyal to a particular product or developer - I simply use the one that’s best for my needs and will honestly tell people if asked.

                                        I frequently mention Scenic on here as I prefer it over MRA for navigation. It meets my needs more than MRA. However, I often mention MRA on the Scenic forum, often with the claim that it’s light years ahead of Scenic for planning. It’s about balance and suitability. I see the MRA/Scenic combo as like having 2 dedicated tools in my toolbox, rather than a Swiss Army knife.

                                        Peter Schieferundefined Offline
                                        Peter Schieferundefined Offline
                                        Peter Schiefer
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #27

                                        @Dae-0
                                        As you could read, I correct myself regard color scheme, it was first a miss translation by me regard user concerns at scenic with Here maps.
                                        And to Corjan, creating own road colors as known from paper maps like Shell or Michelin is a great option.
                                        And as Dea confirmed too, the routing works better. You can select number of announcement for stop points, viapoints and routing instructions, not only for the routing.
                                        MRA has this option only for routing.
                                        Shaping points will not be announced, because normally there is no need. MRA says you can, when you rename the position with no digits or add info.
                                        Reduce this function to POI, stop points only, simliar to Scenic or Garmin.
                                        Currently I test scenic routing engine a bit more, but it seems this is with CarPlay, the own colors and better announcement stability reduced to POIs the reference and perhaps I will use both.

                                        Regard Here or OSM I believe HERE who is working for automotive since decades has and works with more profession. OSM is perhaps too much splitted in interest groups.

                                        Peter

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        0
                                        • Dae 0undefined Dae 0

                                          @Corjan-Meijerink

                                          Absolutely. I was just pointing out the real reason that they’ve left HERE and correcting Peter’s assertion that it’s due to colours.

                                          I’m not loyal to a particular product or developer - I simply use the one that’s best for my needs and will honestly tell people if asked.

                                          I frequently mention Scenic on here as I prefer it over MRA for navigation. It meets my needs more than MRA. However, I often mention MRA on the Scenic forum, often with the claim that it’s light years ahead of Scenic for planning. It’s about balance and suitability. I see the MRA/Scenic combo as like having 2 dedicated tools in my toolbox, rather than a Swiss Army knife.

                                          Con Hennekensundefined Offline
                                          Con Hennekensundefined Offline
                                          Con Hennekens
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #28

                                          @Dae-0, Am I guessing correctly that long-announced Android project is thrown off by this change of map-provider decision?

                                          I am just an enthusiastic MRA user, and hope you will be one too!

                                          Most motorcycle problems are caused by the nut that connects the handlebar to the saddle.

                                          Streetpilot 2610 / Zumo 660 / Zumo 395 / CAT S52 + MRA app

                                          Dae 0undefined 1 Reply Last reply
                                          0
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • 1
                                          • 2
                                          ACTIVE USERS
                                          Corjan Meijerinkundefined
                                          Corjan Meijerink
                                          Nick Carthewundefined
                                          Nick Carthew
                                          white.mouseundefined
                                          white.mouse
                                          Con Hennekensundefined
                                          Con Hennekens
                                          Dae 0undefined
                                          Dae 0
                                          Vincent Currenundefined
                                          Vincent Curren
                                          GT JWRundefined
                                          GT JWR
                                          Peter Schieferundefined
                                          Peter Schiefer
                                          Afterforever666undefined
                                          Afterforever666
                                          POPULAR TOPICS
                                          • Route app werkt helaas nog niet hoe ik het graag zou zien.
                                            P van der Meulenundefined
                                            P van der Meulen
                                            1
                                            13
                                            187

                                          • iOS crashing with Silverfox B8J and panning not working
                                            Corjan Meijerinkundefined
                                            Corjan Meijerink
                                            0
                                            10
                                            126

                                          • Routeapp volgt de routepunten niet.
                                            M. Schrijverundefined
                                            M. Schrijver
                                            0
                                            12
                                            237

                                          • Route does not follow the actual Tom Tom map
                                            silberfuchs67undefined
                                            silberfuchs67
                                            0
                                            13
                                            224

                                          • Google Maps
                                            Nick Carthewundefined
                                            Nick Carthew
                                            3
                                            10
                                            630

                                          • another New user to MRA navigation
                                            Nick Carthewundefined
                                            Nick Carthew
                                            0
                                            4
                                            83

                                          • MRA MyRoute app version 4.3.9 - 395 - only shows a very much zoomed in route.
                                            Con Hennekensundefined
                                            Con Hennekens
                                            0
                                            19
                                            472

                                          • Driving without ETA info bar
                                            white.mouseundefined
                                            white.mouse
                                            2
                                            11
                                            414
                                          MY GROUPS
                                          • Login

                                          • Login or register to search.
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Recent
                                          • Popular
                                          • Support
                                          • MyRoute-app