This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?
-
@Stephen-Rowland Hi Stephen. Yes, that's another little complication. The route I chose to get to the via point takes you on a public access road through the grounds of a stately home. During the day all those gates are open and you can get into the site one way and out the other, as you can see on the route. It's possible, as you say, that planning the route was not a problem but the navigation software baulks at it. When the software did go direct to point 5 I was already at a location where it went in via the "exit" on the planned route, right near the via point.
What I'll do is make a copy of this route and move the via point onto the road as Marinus suggested, but also make a further route that has a similar crossing of the paths but avoids going through the grounds of the stately home.
I'll update this thread early next week.
I was hoping to use MRA with Android Auto for a 750-mile ride this weekend, but its oddities with a 15-mile test route (along with locking solid and needing the phone rebooting) means I'm back to the Nav6, which is a big shame.
@Tim-Watson Hi Tim
Took another glance at it with the PC and then I saw the light:
1: You've made the route with the motor profil on
2: I changed it to auto witch is the only type you can use at this moment with the Here maps. Then it became quit clear. The route that you wanted to go is beeing altered and giving you the route isues that you had.
3 solution: I added a couple of shaping points and that should do the trick.
It looks like this:
Here's the url to the route I've changed:
https://www.myrouteapp.com/route/open/9782354
If you have another testrun I think it will provide you want you wanted.
My comments in the first responce are nevertheless valid. You can see that I've placed the shaping and viapoint ON the route. Thus making shure the desired route is calculated.
make your routes with the auto profil on
Honda Goldwing GL1500,
Honda Silverwing GL 650
DMD2 T865X 8 inch Android tablet using MRA next for navigation
Garmin XT (almost in the cupboard)
Samsung S20FE mounted on a Quadlock and using Android Auto in my car -
@Tim-Watson Hi Tim
Took another glance at it with the PC and then I saw the light:
1: You've made the route with the motor profil on
2: I changed it to auto witch is the only type you can use at this moment with the Here maps. Then it became quit clear. The route that you wanted to go is beeing altered and giving you the route isues that you had.
3 solution: I added a couple of shaping points and that should do the trick.
It looks like this:
Here's the url to the route I've changed:
https://www.myrouteapp.com/route/open/9782354
If you have another testrun I think it will provide you want you wanted.
My comments in the first responce are nevertheless valid. You can see that I've placed the shaping and viapoint ON the route. Thus making shure the desired route is calculated.
make your routes with the auto profil on@Marinus-van-Deudekom Hey Marinus. Thanks very much for taking the time to have another look.
I'm not sure what you mean by the "motor profile". Do you mean the "Transport mode" on the "Start a new route" screen? Possible not, as I can't see an "Auto" option for this. Or do you mean "Auto" as in automobile as in "Car".
Apologies if I'm looking completely in the wrong place!!
If you do mean the problem is that I created the route as "Motorcycle" instead of "Car":
- What is the difference? I've not seen anything in the MRA documentation to say why one would use one type over another
- How does one change the profile for an existing route?
- What did you see change with the route? When I use the bar at the bottom of the route planner to follow my original route, it goes the correct way
Thanks again for your time!!
-
@Marinus-van-Deudekom Hey Marinus. Thanks very much for taking the time to have another look.
I'm not sure what you mean by the "motor profile". Do you mean the "Transport mode" on the "Start a new route" screen? Possible not, as I can't see an "Auto" option for this. Or do you mean "Auto" as in automobile as in "Car".
Apologies if I'm looking completely in the wrong place!!
If you do mean the problem is that I created the route as "Motorcycle" instead of "Car":
- What is the difference? I've not seen anything in the MRA documentation to say why one would use one type over another
- How does one change the profile for an existing route?
- What did you see change with the route? When I use the bar at the bottom of the route planner to follow my original route, it goes the correct way
Thanks again for your time!!
@Tim-Watson
Hi Tim if you change the settings that's what happens. The motorcycle profil is not usefull at this moment in time>
You can change is here
-
@Marinus-van-Deudekom Hey Marinus. Thanks very much for taking the time to have another look.
I'm not sure what you mean by the "motor profile". Do you mean the "Transport mode" on the "Start a new route" screen? Possible not, as I can't see an "Auto" option for this. Or do you mean "Auto" as in automobile as in "Car".
Apologies if I'm looking completely in the wrong place!!
If you do mean the problem is that I created the route as "Motorcycle" instead of "Car":
- What is the difference? I've not seen anything in the MRA documentation to say why one would use one type over another
- How does one change the profile for an existing route?
- What did you see change with the route? When I use the bar at the bottom of the route planner to follow my original route, it goes the correct way
Thanks again for your time!!
@Tim-Watson If you change the transport mode in your route to car you can see yourself what happens.
then I added a couple of shapingpoints to force the route the way is wasHonda Goldwing GL1500,
Honda Silverwing GL 650
DMD2 T865X 8 inch Android tablet using MRA next for navigation
Garmin XT (almost in the cupboard)
Samsung S20FE mounted on a Quadlock and using Android Auto in my car -
@Marinus-van-Deudekom Hey Marinus. Thanks very much for taking the time to have another look.
I'm not sure what you mean by the "motor profile". Do you mean the "Transport mode" on the "Start a new route" screen? Possible not, as I can't see an "Auto" option for this. Or do you mean "Auto" as in automobile as in "Car".
Apologies if I'm looking completely in the wrong place!!
If you do mean the problem is that I created the route as "Motorcycle" instead of "Car":
- What is the difference? I've not seen anything in the MRA documentation to say why one would use one type over another
- How does one change the profile for an existing route?
- What did you see change with the route? When I use the bar at the bottom of the route planner to follow my original route, it goes the correct way
Thanks again for your time!!
-
@Tim-Watson If you change the transport mode in your route to car you can see yourself what happens.
then I added a couple of shapingpoints to force the route the way is was@Marinus-van-Deudekom Thank you!
Wow, by changing the Transport mode from Motorcycle to Car the route length instantly changed from 14.54 to 18.92 miles.
I'm really grateful you found that, and I look forward to testing it.
However, I'm intrigued why the devs put the Transport mode in, and allowed a default mode other than Car to be set in the user profile, when only the Car profile works with the only map supported by the app?
I can see the Transport mode changes something, but is it documented anywhere what is changing? I would expect this route to navigate the same by car, motorcycle or camel!
-
@Marinus-van-Deudekom Thank you!
Wow, by changing the Transport mode from Motorcycle to Car the route length instantly changed from 14.54 to 18.92 miles.
I'm really grateful you found that, and I look forward to testing it.
However, I'm intrigued why the devs put the Transport mode in, and allowed a default mode other than Car to be set in the user profile, when only the Car profile works with the only map supported by the app?
I can see the Transport mode changes something, but is it documented anywhere what is changing? I would expect this route to navigate the same by car, motorcycle or camel!
@Tim-Watson That I don't know, my camel riding skills are close to none
Driving by car or motorcycle is the same as far as Here is concerned. The other profiles like motorhome actually have impact on the route.
For now just use the car profile and enjoy your rides -
@Tim-Watson Hi Tim
Your shapingpoint 6 and especially your viapoint 5 are off the route. My guess is that due to the crossing in the route MRA couldn't determine the right path do therefore skipped viapoint 5 and calculated as it did.
Could you try it again with the points exactly on the route. To do so make sure you zoom in Max@Marinus-van-Deudekom said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
My guess is that due to the crossing in the route MRA couldn't determine the right path do therefore skipped viapoint 5 and calculated as it did.
A VIA point is there to NOT be autoskipped. If a waypoint is too far off a road so that it cannot be reached, you will get a warning and the route wil not start at all. So I do not think that is it.
@Tim-Watson, do I understand correctly that you were navigating this route on your Nav6? In that case the device itself chooses how to navigate between waypoints. the (non?) logic to skip WP5 therefore is inherent to the device, not the route. It looks like a really small loop. Maybe there is some logic in the device to prevent those (usually unwanted) loops, I really cant say.
I am just an enthusiastic MRA user, and hope you will be one too!
Most motorcycle problems are caused by the nut that connects the handlebar to the saddle.
Streetpilot 2610/Zumo 660/Zumo 395/ CAT S52 + MRA app -
@Tim-Watson Hi Tim
Took another glance at it with the PC and then I saw the light:
1: You've made the route with the motor profil on
2: I changed it to auto witch is the only type you can use at this moment with the Here maps. Then it became quit clear. The route that you wanted to go is beeing altered and giving you the route isues that you had.
3 solution: I added a couple of shaping points and that should do the trick.
It looks like this:
Here's the url to the route I've changed:
https://www.myrouteapp.com/route/open/9782354
If you have another testrun I think it will provide you want you wanted.
My comments in the first responce are nevertheless valid. You can see that I've placed the shaping and viapoint ON the route. Thus making shure the desired route is calculated.
make your routes with the auto profil on@Marinus-van-Deudekom said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
1: You've made the route with the motor profil on
2: I changed it to auto witch is the only type you can use at this moment with the Here maps.Although there have been some problems related to the Motorbike profile, it is absolutely untrue to says that it does not work with HERE maps. It is perfectly usable, even if there are circumstances in which it might be better to use CAR profile instead.
I am just an enthusiastic MRA user, and hope you will be one too!
Most motorcycle problems are caused by the nut that connects the handlebar to the saddle.
Streetpilot 2610/Zumo 660/Zumo 395/ CAT S52 + MRA app -
@Marinus-van-Deudekom said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
My guess is that due to the crossing in the route MRA couldn't determine the right path do therefore skipped viapoint 5 and calculated as it did.
A VIA point is there to NOT be autoskipped. If a waypoint is too far off a road so that it cannot be reached, you will get a warning and the route wil not start at all. So I do not think that is it.
@Tim-Watson, do I understand correctly that you were navigating this route on your Nav6? In that case the device itself chooses how to navigate between waypoints. the (non?) logic to skip WP5 therefore is inherent to the device, not the route. It looks like a really small loop. Maybe there is some logic in the device to prevent those (usually unwanted) loops, I really cant say.
@Con-Hennekens Hi. No, I used a Nav6 before this week, but this week am trying out MRA and a Chigee with Android Auto. It's not going very well. Back to the Nav6 for now.
-
@Marinus-van-Deudekom said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
1: You've made the route with the motor profil on
2: I changed it to auto witch is the only type you can use at this moment with the Here maps.Although there have been some problems related to the Motorbike profile, it is absolutely untrue to says that it does not work with HERE maps. It is perfectly usable, even if there are circumstances in which it might be better to use CAR profile instead.
Although there have been some problems related to the Motorbike profile, it is absolutely untrue to says that it does not work with HERE maps. It is perfectly usable, even if there are circumstances in which it might be better to use CAR profile instead.
Can you explain what these problems with the motorcycle profile have been? I can't find anything that says which to use, or indeed which to avoid.
-
@Marinus-van-Deudekom said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
1: You've made the route with the motor profil on
2: I changed it to auto witch is the only type you can use at this moment with the Here maps.Although there have been some problems related to the Motorbike profile, it is absolutely untrue to says that it does not work with HERE maps. It is perfectly usable, even if there are circumstances in which it might be better to use CAR profile instead.
@Con-Hennekens hoi @Con-Hennekens
The advice from the devs is not to use the profile. Like in Tim's case it causes problems that at completely unnecessary. I agree with the devs. Maybe you can explain what would be useful in the bike profile. I could guess like maybe road closures für bikes but I experienced that even that doesn't work at this time. What could be the advantage of that profile.Honda Goldwing GL1500,
Honda Silverwing GL 650
DMD2 T865X 8 inch Android tablet using MRA next for navigation
Garmin XT (almost in the cupboard)
Samsung S20FE mounted on a Quadlock and using Android Auto in my car -
@Con-Hennekens hoi @Con-Hennekens
The advice from the devs is not to use the profile. Like in Tim's case it causes problems that at completely unnecessary. I agree with the devs. Maybe you can explain what would be useful in the bike profile. I could guess like maybe road closures für bikes but I experienced that even that doesn't work at this time. What could be the advantage of that profile.Maybe @Corjan-Meijerink can give an authoritative answer straight from the horse’s mouth on the use of the motorcycle profile, both in planning mode and navigation mode (some of us only use MRA for planning).
It’s important to know if we shouldn’t be using these modes, and if it is the case then it needs to be made more prominent to stop new users being unaware and having a really bad experience. You can see from the original post in this thread that the new user has gone back to the Nav VI because of a bad experience. That’s not good if the root cause is something that was known about but poorly communicated.
-
Hallo,
Please look at,
Toolkit / Avoid / Unpaved Roads
These settings must be readjusted for each new route, Why?
-
Maybe @Corjan-Meijerink can give an authoritative answer straight from the horse’s mouth on the use of the motorcycle profile, both in planning mode and navigation mode (some of us only use MRA for planning).
It’s important to know if we shouldn’t be using these modes, and if it is the case then it needs to be made more prominent to stop new users being unaware and having a really bad experience. You can see from the original post in this thread that the new user has gone back to the Nav VI because of a bad experience. That’s not good if the root cause is something that was known about but poorly communicated.
@Dae-0 said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
Maybe @Corjan-Meijerink can give an authoritative answer straight from the horse’s mouth on the use of the motorcycle profile, both in planning mode and navigation mode (some of us only use MRA for planning).
I happen to know that @Corjan-Meijerink uses the motorbike profile almost exclusively himself. The motorbike profile is there because it is included in the HERE SDK. Maybe Corjan cares to elaborate?
Roads exist that are closed for 4 wheels, but are open for 2 wheels.
Closures with this sign are not closed for motorbikes. I can only assume the motorbike profile takes that into account correctly.
@Tim-Watson said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
Can you explain what these problems with the motorcycle profile have been?
There was a problem with showing the wrong exit at roundabouts that appeared to be exclusively for the motorbike profile. I understand that this has been solved for some time already.
Also there is an ongoing problem where route optimization as "shortest" instead of "quickest" is not available for the motorbike profile. That is mainly a problem if you want to go over scheduled ferries. In that case it is advised to switch to car profile and the "shortest route" optimization.
I am just an enthusiastic MRA user, and hope you will be one too!
Most motorcycle problems are caused by the nut that connects the handlebar to the saddle.
Streetpilot 2610/Zumo 660/Zumo 395/ CAT S52 + MRA app -
@Dae-0 said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
Maybe @Corjan-Meijerink can give an authoritative answer straight from the horse’s mouth on the use of the motorcycle profile, both in planning mode and navigation mode (some of us only use MRA for planning).
I happen to know that @Corjan-Meijerink uses the motorbike profile almost exclusively himself. The motorbike profile is there because it is included in the HERE SDK. Maybe Corjan cares to elaborate?
Roads exist that are closed for 4 wheels, but are open for 2 wheels.
Closures with this sign are not closed for motorbikes. I can only assume the motorbike profile takes that into account correctly.
@Tim-Watson said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
Can you explain what these problems with the motorcycle profile have been?
There was a problem with showing the wrong exit at roundabouts that appeared to be exclusively for the motorbike profile. I understand that this has been solved for some time already.
Also there is an ongoing problem where route optimization as "shortest" instead of "quickest" is not available for the motorbike profile. That is mainly a problem if you want to go over scheduled ferries. In that case it is advised to switch to car profile and the "shortest route" optimization.
@Con-Hennekens this is what I mean @Con-Hennekens the bike profile doesn’t look at the closed roads for bikes. I Hope @Corjan-Meijerink will give his final verdict so we can close this part of the subject
Honda Goldwing GL1500,
Honda Silverwing GL 650
DMD2 T865X 8 inch Android tablet using MRA next for navigation
Garmin XT (almost in the cupboard)
Samsung S20FE mounted on a Quadlock and using Android Auto in my car -
Maybe @Corjan-Meijerink can give an authoritative answer straight from the horse’s mouth on the use of the motorcycle profile, both in planning mode and navigation mode (some of us only use MRA for planning).
It’s important to know if we shouldn’t be using these modes, and if it is the case then it needs to be made more prominent to stop new users being unaware and having a really bad experience. You can see from the original post in this thread that the new user has gone back to the Nav VI because of a bad experience. That’s not good if the root cause is something that was known about but poorly communicated.
@Dae-0 said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
You can see from the original post in this thread that the new user has gone back to the Nav VI because of a bad experience. That’s not good if the root cause is something that was known about but poorly communicated.
That for sure is true. However it is known that almost no one reads such a documentation. Most people just ask questions on the forum, and many users are here to help
Concerning @Tim-Watson his bad experience, it is very likely that probably unintentional some skipping buttons were pressed. A VIA point (hand symbol) does not get skipped automatically. Therefore it is good info whether the problem reoccurs. If it does, it is best to submit a support ticket, so the devs can ask for logs to check what's wrong.
-
@Con-Hennekens this is what I mean @Con-Hennekens the bike profile doesn’t look at the closed roads for bikes. I Hope @Corjan-Meijerink will give his final verdict so we can close this part of the subject
@Marinus-van-Deudekom said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
the bike profile doesn’t look at the closed roads for bikes.
Can you substantiate that with an example? It would be very good to know, and to mention to HERE.
I am just an enthusiastic MRA user, and hope you will be one too!
Most motorcycle problems are caused by the nut that connects the handlebar to the saddle.
Streetpilot 2610/Zumo 660/Zumo 395/ CAT S52 + MRA app -
@Marinus-van-Deudekom said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
the bike profile doesn’t look at the closed roads for bikes.
Can you substantiate that with an example? It would be very good to know, and to mention to HERE.
@Con-Hennekens yes I can
Making an route for my RouteXpert training I couldn’t find why a street was impossible to drive trough with the OSM. Looking at the situation Sith streetview I discovered that thé Riad was closed for bikes. Here and TomTom didn’t have that problem. Changing to the bike profile didn’t change anything. So for once OSM was right.
Other example if you want to cross a river by ferry. Most of the times the bike profile will lead to a non ferry crossing of the river where when using the car profile you can cross the river by ferryHonda Goldwing GL1500,
Honda Silverwing GL 650
DMD2 T865X 8 inch Android tablet using MRA next for navigation
Garmin XT (almost in the cupboard)
Samsung S20FE mounted on a Quadlock and using Android Auto in my car -
@Con-Hennekens yes I can
Making an route for my RouteXpert training I couldn’t find why a street was impossible to drive trough with the OSM. Looking at the situation Sith streetview I discovered that thé Riad was closed for bikes. Here and TomTom didn’t have that problem. Changing to the bike profile didn’t change anything. So for once OSM was right.
Other example if you want to cross a river by ferry. Most of the times the bike profile will lead to a non ferry crossing of the river where when using the car profile you can cross the river by ferry@Marinus-van-Deudekom said in This is routing incorrectly isn't it?!?:
Making an route for my RouteXpert training I couldn’t find why a street was impossible to drive trough with the OSM. Looking at the situation Sith streetview I discovered that thé Riad was closed for bikes. Here and TomTom didn’t have that problem. Changing to the bike profile didn’t change anything. So for once OSM was right.
Yes, but that does not proof that the motorbike profile does not honor the car-only closure correctly. It more like proofs that HERE and TomTom are unaware (yet) of the bike-closure. Did you check that with HERE and TomTom?
Other example if you want to cross a river by ferry. Most of the times the bike profile will lead to a non ferry crossing of the river where when using the car profile you can cross the river by ferry
I already explained that above, and this is also no proof of the motorbike profile to disregard roads that are open for bikes but not for cars.
I am just an enthusiastic MRA user, and hope you will be one too!
Most motorcycle problems are caused by the nut that connects the handlebar to the saddle.
Streetpilot 2610/Zumo 660/Zumo 395/ CAT S52 + MRA app
