Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Support
  • MyRoute-app
Collapse
Brand Logo

MRA Community Forum

  1. Home
  2. MyRoute-app Routeplanner
  3. [Web] Problems, Bugs and other Issues
  4. Travel time discrepancies

Travel time discrepancies

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved [Web] Problems, Bugs and other Issues
26 Posts 6 Posters 2.6k Views 4 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Steve Jarrellundefined Steve Jarrell

    @Martin-Wilcke It looks like MRA is using the Garmin extensions to do their track and route calculations whereas Kurviger doesn't. The strange part is that for this exact same route if I use the OSM map in MRA the calculated time shows as 3:13, with the TomTom map it's 3:11 (both are close to the actual time that it took to ride the route and the time calculated by Google and Kurviger) and with the HERE map it is 4:17.

    Gpx 1.1 files exported by all three maps show that the tracks created used the Garmin extensions, however the actual route creation calculations must be a function of the underlying map itself.

    I pointed out in another post that the HERE map consistently does not follow an imported track as well as the other two, and the route's time calculations are definitely inferior as well.

    I definitely see the disadvantages of using the HERE map over using the OSM map in MRA. Can anyone tell me the actual advantages?

    Thanks!

    Herman Veldhuizenundefined Offline
    Herman Veldhuizenundefined Offline
    Herman Veldhuizen
    wrote on last edited by
    #12

    @Steve-Jarrell A small note on the side. I tried Kurviger a while ago and found the ETA's, while navigating, far too conservative (the rides were taking me less time). This was when driving a car on asfalt roads. They definitely don't include live traffic data and I think they have their own algorithm to calculate the ETA's. The ETA info to the next waypoint is a very important feature for my use cases and the conservative estimates in Kurviger were the main reason for me to switch to MRA (where I found the ETAs to be very accurate).

    Steve Jarrellundefined 1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • Steve Jarrellundefined Steve Jarrell

      @Martin-Wilcke It looks like MRA is using the Garmin extensions to do their track and route calculations whereas Kurviger doesn't. The strange part is that for this exact same route if I use the OSM map in MRA the calculated time shows as 3:13, with the TomTom map it's 3:11 (both are close to the actual time that it took to ride the route and the time calculated by Google and Kurviger) and with the HERE map it is 4:17.

      Gpx 1.1 files exported by all three maps show that the tracks created used the Garmin extensions, however the actual route creation calculations must be a function of the underlying map itself.

      I pointed out in another post that the HERE map consistently does not follow an imported track as well as the other two, and the route's time calculations are definitely inferior as well.

      I definitely see the disadvantages of using the HERE map over using the OSM map in MRA. Can anyone tell me the actual advantages?

      Thanks!

      Martin Wilckeundefined Offline
      Martin Wilckeundefined Offline
      Martin Wilcke
      wrote on last edited by
      #13

      @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

      It looks like MRA is using the Garmin extensions to do their track and route calculations whereas Kurviger doesn't.

      To avoid confusion: Using GPX extensions (like "Garmin extensions") is a way to store additional information in a gpx file that is not part of the core gpx data model. The most popular example is the differentiation between VIA and shaping route points using the garmin:trp extension.

      For time information, however, there is no need to use an extension as this is part of the core gpx data model.

      And it's about storing information and has nothing to do with time calculation.

      Steve Jarrellundefined 1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • Steve Jarrellundefined Steve Jarrell

        @Martin-Wilcke It looks like MRA is using the Garmin extensions to do their track and route calculations whereas Kurviger doesn't. The strange part is that for this exact same route if I use the OSM map in MRA the calculated time shows as 3:13, with the TomTom map it's 3:11 (both are close to the actual time that it took to ride the route and the time calculated by Google and Kurviger) and with the HERE map it is 4:17.

        Gpx 1.1 files exported by all three maps show that the tracks created used the Garmin extensions, however the actual route creation calculations must be a function of the underlying map itself.

        I pointed out in another post that the HERE map consistently does not follow an imported track as well as the other two, and the route's time calculations are definitely inferior as well.

        I definitely see the disadvantages of using the HERE map over using the OSM map in MRA. Can anyone tell me the actual advantages?

        Thanks!

        Martin Wilckeundefined Offline
        Martin Wilckeundefined Offline
        Martin Wilcke
        wrote on last edited by
        #14

        @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

        I definitely see the disadvantages of using the HERE map over using the OSM map in MRA. Can anyone tell me the actual advantages?

        There is one I'm aware of: consideration of road closures.

        Steve Jarrellundefined 1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • Herman Veldhuizenundefined Herman Veldhuizen

          @Steve-Jarrell A small note on the side. I tried Kurviger a while ago and found the ETA's, while navigating, far too conservative (the rides were taking me less time). This was when driving a car on asfalt roads. They definitely don't include live traffic data and I think they have their own algorithm to calculate the ETA's. The ETA info to the next waypoint is a very important feature for my use cases and the conservative estimates in Kurviger were the main reason for me to switch to MRA (where I found the ETAs to be very accurate).

          Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
          Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
          Steve Jarrell
          Valued contributor
          wrote on last edited by
          #15

          @Herman-Veldhuizen Thanks for your respons Herman. With the TomTom and OSM maps I'm finding the calculated route times to be very accurate. With the HERE maps I find it to be inconsistent.

          The only thing that I can surmise is that the route calculations and the calculations that create a route from a track are built into the maps themselves and MRA has very little, if any, control over them otherwise the HERE map would not be inferior to the other two in this regard.

          I also switched from Kurviger as I find the user interface to be very, very unintuitive whereas I find MRA to be extremely easy to use. I also find MRA's tech support to be excellent, and the user forum is extremely helpful as well.

          Unless someone can show me why there are important advantages to using the HERE maps as the default I'm going to make the OSM maps my default, and hopefully the MRA developers will fix the bug that causes the following dialog to appear when I switch to the OSM map or import a track into it even though I have my driving mode set to "Driving" which, according to MRA, should avoid this message:

          Dialog.jpg

          Herman Veldhuizenundefined Con Hennekensundefined 2 Replies Last reply
          0
          • Steve Jarrellundefined Steve Jarrell

            @Herman-Veldhuizen Thanks for your respons Herman. With the TomTom and OSM maps I'm finding the calculated route times to be very accurate. With the HERE maps I find it to be inconsistent.

            The only thing that I can surmise is that the route calculations and the calculations that create a route from a track are built into the maps themselves and MRA has very little, if any, control over them otherwise the HERE map would not be inferior to the other two in this regard.

            I also switched from Kurviger as I find the user interface to be very, very unintuitive whereas I find MRA to be extremely easy to use. I also find MRA's tech support to be excellent, and the user forum is extremely helpful as well.

            Unless someone can show me why there are important advantages to using the HERE maps as the default I'm going to make the OSM maps my default, and hopefully the MRA developers will fix the bug that causes the following dialog to appear when I switch to the OSM map or import a track into it even though I have my driving mode set to "Driving" which, according to MRA, should avoid this message:

            Dialog.jpg

            Herman Veldhuizenundefined Offline
            Herman Veldhuizenundefined Offline
            Herman Veldhuizen
            wrote on last edited by Herman Veldhuizen
            #16

            @Steve-Jarrell I never really looked at the route times, only the ETAs while navigating.
            But now I did for one of my routes which goes mostly over a highway
            Route time for MRA-OSM is noticeably longer than MRA-Here! Kurviger is the slowest.
            220km, paths are very similar in all 3.

            MRA Here: 2h 52m
            MRA OSM: 3h 13m
            Kurviger: 4h 4m

            Steve Jarrellundefined 1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • Herman Veldhuizenundefined Herman Veldhuizen

              @Steve-Jarrell I never really looked at the route times, only the ETAs while navigating.
              But now I did for one of my routes which goes mostly over a highway
              Route time for MRA-OSM is noticeably longer than MRA-Here! Kurviger is the slowest.
              220km, paths are very similar in all 3.

              MRA Here: 2h 52m
              MRA OSM: 3h 13m
              Kurviger: 4h 4m

              Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
              Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
              Steve Jarrell
              Valued contributor
              wrote on last edited by
              #17

              @Herman-Veldhuizen Thanks Herman.. That's weird..... there doesn't seem to be any consistency. My "gold standard" is normally Waze or Google maps as I find them to be extremely accurate, but since you can't upload a specific route into either they're of no help. Although you can import a track into Google MyMaps it really doesn't create a Google route from it, so it uses the tracks time information so that's no help.

              I could be wrong so if I am someone please let me know. I'm here to learn.... that's half the fun! 🙂

              If I have time I'll go back and compare 5 or 6 of our group's tracks/routes and compare them in MRA using the HERE, OSM and TomTom maps.

              Thanks for your input. I really appreciate it!

              1 Reply Last reply
              0
              • Steve Jarrellundefined Steve Jarrell

                @Herman-Veldhuizen Thanks for your respons Herman. With the TomTom and OSM maps I'm finding the calculated route times to be very accurate. With the HERE maps I find it to be inconsistent.

                The only thing that I can surmise is that the route calculations and the calculations that create a route from a track are built into the maps themselves and MRA has very little, if any, control over them otherwise the HERE map would not be inferior to the other two in this regard.

                I also switched from Kurviger as I find the user interface to be very, very unintuitive whereas I find MRA to be extremely easy to use. I also find MRA's tech support to be excellent, and the user forum is extremely helpful as well.

                Unless someone can show me why there are important advantages to using the HERE maps as the default I'm going to make the OSM maps my default, and hopefully the MRA developers will fix the bug that causes the following dialog to appear when I switch to the OSM map or import a track into it even though I have my driving mode set to "Driving" which, according to MRA, should avoid this message:

                Dialog.jpg

                Con Hennekensundefined Offline
                Con Hennekensundefined Offline
                Con Hennekens
                Alpha tester
                wrote on last edited by
                #18

                @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

                Unless someone can show me why there are important advantages to using the HERE maps as the default I'm going to make the OSM maps my default

                The biggest advantage to use HERE maps for planning is the least chance for the planner map to be different than the navigation map. The advice is to plan your route on map that is ost equal to the one you navigate with. For MRA Navigation that is HERE, as is for Garmin devices. There are many differences in maps between OSM and HERE, especially in rural mountenesque areas.

                @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

                the bug that causes the following dialog to appear when I switch to the OSM map or import a track into it even though I have my driving mode set to "Driving"

                I am not aware of a driving mode called "driving". I only get this message when I switch from HERE or TomTom to OSM while I have "Motorbike" selected as driving mode.

                I am just an enthusiastic MRA user, and hope you will be one too!

                Most motorcycle problems are caused by the nut that connects the handlebar to the saddle.

                Streetpilot 2610 / Zumo 660 / Zumo 395 / CAT S52 + MRA app

                Steve Jarrellundefined 2 Replies Last reply
                0
                • Martin Wilckeundefined Martin Wilcke

                  @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

                  It looks like MRA is using the Garmin extensions to do their track and route calculations whereas Kurviger doesn't.

                  To avoid confusion: Using GPX extensions (like "Garmin extensions") is a way to store additional information in a gpx file that is not part of the core gpx data model. The most popular example is the differentiation between VIA and shaping route points using the garmin:trp extension.

                  For time information, however, there is no need to use an extension as this is part of the core gpx data model.

                  And it's about storing information and has nothing to do with time calculation.

                  Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                  Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                  Steve Jarrell
                  Valued contributor
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #19

                  @Martin-Wilcke Thank you for the explanation!

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • Martin Wilckeundefined Martin Wilcke

                    @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

                    I definitely see the disadvantages of using the HERE map over using the OSM map in MRA. Can anyone tell me the actual advantages?

                    There is one I'm aware of: consideration of road closures.

                    Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                    Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                    Steve Jarrell
                    Valued contributor
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #20

                    @Martin-Wilcke Thank you.

                    That's one that I prefer not to use anyway as I've found (in our area at least) that often it's not accurate, or I'm creating a route that I'll be riding when they don't exist so I almost always disable it anyway.

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • Con Hennekensundefined Con Hennekens

                      @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

                      Unless someone can show me why there are important advantages to using the HERE maps as the default I'm going to make the OSM maps my default

                      The biggest advantage to use HERE maps for planning is the least chance for the planner map to be different than the navigation map. The advice is to plan your route on map that is ost equal to the one you navigate with. For MRA Navigation that is HERE, as is for Garmin devices. There are many differences in maps between OSM and HERE, especially in rural mountenesque areas.

                      @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

                      the bug that causes the following dialog to appear when I switch to the OSM map or import a track into it even though I have my driving mode set to "Driving"

                      I am not aware of a driving mode called "driving". I only get this message when I switch from HERE or TomTom to OSM while I have "Motorbike" selected as driving mode.

                      Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                      Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                      Steve Jarrell
                      Valued contributor
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #21

                      @Con-Hennekens You are right. My mistake. It's called "Car" so I'm not set on Motorcycle, but I still get the message every time I switch to OSM. What driving mode are you using in your profile?

                      Thanks!

                      mode.jpg

                      BertMundefined 1 Reply Last reply
                      0
                      • Con Hennekensundefined Con Hennekens

                        @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

                        Unless someone can show me why there are important advantages to using the HERE maps as the default I'm going to make the OSM maps my default

                        The biggest advantage to use HERE maps for planning is the least chance for the planner map to be different than the navigation map. The advice is to plan your route on map that is ost equal to the one you navigate with. For MRA Navigation that is HERE, as is for Garmin devices. There are many differences in maps between OSM and HERE, especially in rural mountenesque areas.

                        @Steve-Jarrell said in Travel time discrepancies:

                        the bug that causes the following dialog to appear when I switch to the OSM map or import a track into it even though I have my driving mode set to "Driving"

                        I am not aware of a driving mode called "driving". I only get this message when I switch from HERE or TomTom to OSM while I have "Motorbike" selected as driving mode.

                        Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                        Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                        Steve Jarrell
                        Valued contributor
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #22

                        @Con-Hennekens I overlooked the first part of your post. Thanks for the detailed explanation!

                        Steve

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • Steve Jarrellundefined Steve Jarrell

                          @Con-Hennekens You are right. My mistake. It's called "Car" so I'm not set on Motorcycle, but I still get the message every time I switch to OSM. What driving mode are you using in your profile?

                          Thanks!

                          mode.jpg

                          BertMundefined Offline
                          BertMundefined Offline
                          BertM
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #23

                          @Steve-Jarrell
                          When i open de route you linked in a previous post the profile is set to motorcycle…

                          BertMundefined Steve Jarrellundefined 2 Replies Last reply
                          0
                          • BertMundefined BertM

                            @Steve-Jarrell
                            When i open de route you linked in a previous post the profile is set to motorcycle…

                            BertMundefined Offline
                            BertMundefined Offline
                            BertM
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #24

                            @BertM ![alt text](IMG_0486.jpeg image url)

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            0
                            • BertMundefined BertM

                              @Steve-Jarrell
                              When i open de route you linked in a previous post the profile is set to motorcycle…

                              Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                              Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                              Steve Jarrell
                              Valued contributor
                              wrote on last edited by Steve Jarrell
                              #25

                              @BertM Yes, I've changed it back and forth several time experimenting trying to figure out what's going on.

                              If you look at my previous post you'll see where I took a screenshot of my profile setting set to "Car' at the exact same time that the error message is appearing.

                              I even thought that perhaps MRA considered the routing mode when the route was created from the track and then ignored it from then on, however I created the route from scratch by importing a .gpx file with the mode set to Car, and as soon as I did I got the error message.

                              Thanks for the response!

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • Corjan Meijerinkundefined Corjan Meijerink

                                It's specifically the road after waypoint 26 that gives way longer estimates than other map sources. It's based on the realistic travel time HERE tracks for that section and my guess is that their data on that is wrong.

                                Either incorrect speed limit or some anomalies in their realistic travel time estimation

                                Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                                Steve Jarrellundefined Offline
                                Steve Jarrell
                                Valued contributor
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #26

                                @Corjan-Meijerink After riding the route last Wednesday it is possible the HERE map is using information about the roads when they were really torn up after Hurricane Helene at the end of last year as some of them were still in pretty bad shape when we rode them and you could see where one lane the road had been washed completely out.

                                If the HERE map is using data from late last year it is likely that at that time their estimation of the time that it would take to ride this route would be accurate. Perhaps a future map update will resolve the issue. That's a very plausible explanation.

                                Thanks! I don't like mysteries, and I'll consider this one solved! 🙂

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                Reply
                                • Reply as topic
                                Log in to reply
                                • Oldest to Newest
                                • Newest to Oldest
                                • Most Votes


                                • 1
                                • 2
                                ACTIVE USERS
                                Corjan Meijerinkundefined
                                Corjan Meijerink
                                Con Hennekensundefined
                                Con Hennekens
                                Herman Veldhuizenundefined
                                Herman Veldhuizen
                                Steve Jarrellundefined
                                Steve Jarrell
                                BertMundefined
                                BertM
                                Martin Wilckeundefined
                                Martin Wilcke
                                POPULAR TOPICS
                                • Scenic routing & RouteXpert library improvements
                                  Edwin_Mundefined
                                  Edwin_M
                                  7
                                  15
                                  583

                                • Scherm indeling MRA routeplanner
                                  Corjan Meijerinkundefined
                                  Corjan Meijerink
                                  0
                                  6
                                  55

                                • Traag web en Android.
                                  Corjan Meijerinkundefined
                                  Corjan Meijerink
                                  0
                                  3
                                  42

                                • Route crash on pc
                                  Corjan Meijerinkundefined
                                  Corjan Meijerink
                                  0
                                  3
                                  47

                                • Trace en rouge
                                  Con Hennekensundefined
                                  Con Hennekens
                                  0
                                  2
                                  23

                                • Tracklog lost
                                  Stanisławundefined
                                  Stanisław
                                  0
                                  7
                                  227

                                • Myroute-app routeplanner
                                  Stanisławundefined
                                  Stanisław
                                  0
                                  5
                                  151

                                • DMD T665 Phone + MyRoute App?
                                  Guzzistundefined
                                  Guzzist
                                  0
                                  4
                                  144
                                MY GROUPS
                                • Login

                                • Login or register to search.
                                • First post
                                  Last post
                                0
                                • Categories
                                • Recent
                                • Popular
                                • Support
                                • MyRoute-app