using GPS coordinates for planning not always correct

[Con Hennekens]

@Brian-McG, just a small tip: you can link to any sub-comment in a thread by using the perma-link of that specific comment:

https://forum.myrouteapp.com/post/72380

[Hubert Thoring]

@Robert-Laudensack said in using GPS coordinates for planning not always correct:

I am using MRA to plan long trips (currently in the Arabian Peninsula).
I use Goggle Map to find interesting places Historic landmarks, hotels, etc. to add them as way points I copy the GPS coordinates from Goggle maps into MRA search. mostly it works out, but it gets it wrong often enough, especially since the search results are shown in Arabic its very hard to validate if it is the spot I wanted at all.
E.g. I want to visit the "Ugarit Ruins" in Syria I copy 35.59840534739703, 35.735457306242395 and paste it ... it shows "Syria" in the middle of the Mediterranean
NB: It is not always possible to search for the place as writing sometimes differ heavily ...
There is a way to add a way point manually based on GPS coordinates, but why is that not an option in the search results e.g. as the 1st result?

That would be the one on the bottom left of the picture. POI : 35.58847633739218, 35.735054719310426
There are two with the same name there... see picture.

Right-click on the POI to select the correct data for copying.

[Robert Laudensack]

@Brian-McG Sorry, but they are not, they are in the "correct order" as Goggle shows them. it depends a bit where exactly you click

BTW why in the world would I go through the effort swapping them ....

[Robert Laudensack]

thanks for your answers, but somehow you are ignoring my point: Why is are the GPS Coordinates not offered as the first search result?
The search option is much more prominent than this tiny little pin (which I only noted recently).
It would be a much better UX

[Nick Carthew]

@Robert-Laudensack When I enter your coordinates into Google Maps it also shows a position in the Mediterranean Sea.

https://maps.app.goo.gl/MJ741TETbzk75xzA7?g_st=ic

[Con Hennekens]

@Robert-Laudensack said in using GPS coordinates for planning not always correct:

BTW why in the world would I go through the effort swapping them ....

There are tools that unintentionally do that. But that is not the case here.
I see no problem at all. It is just that your coordinates are wrong

WP5 are your coordinates
WP6 is the ruines @ 35.58846318787982, 35.735021769743966
(coordinates from Google)

[Con Hennekens]

said in using GPS coordinates for planning not always correct:

WP5 are your coordinates
WP6 is the ruines @ 35.58846318787982, 35.735021769743966

Excuse me, I got them mixed up. Of course it is the other way around.

[Robert Laudensack]

@Nick-Carthew you are right ... its a particularity with goggle maps which i did not fully understand:
I moused-over the name "Ugarit Ruins" and then right clicked to get the coordinates, however I got the Coordinates of the mouse pointer .... I should have used the "share" option.

However i ended up still in the proximity. And not hundred of km away because MRA does not find anything in the proximity of the Coordinates and I can't read arabic ....

[Nick Carthew]

@Robert-Laudensack Have you tried using the Google overlay map in MyRoute-app?
There would be no need to copy and paste coordinates then.
And if you do use coordinates, use the coordinates button that I have arrow Ed to add them rather than the search box.

[Robert Laudensack]

OK, I played a bit more around with with Goggle.maps to write my response and its rather hard to get the exact GPS locations from a landmark: with right click it takes the GPS Coordinates of the mouse pointer and not the the ones of the POI selected, which then leads into getting the wrong position on MRA and the mislead discussion before .....
You all have been ignoring my point that this happens when the results are shown in arab or any other alphabet we typically can't read, because for Waypoints in NL you can read the description and understand if it is the point you wanted or not.

Suggestions
a) show the GPS coordinates or "GPS" behind the search result or mark it in a special way so its clear (1)
b) try to prefer Western text in search results (1 and 2)
c) can you accept "Plus Code" Coordinates from Goggle, as they are always shown with PoI's and I hope they point to the right GPS in the end. ("98RR+MJ Hilla, Irak" for this point)

here another example (Borsippa Ziggurat approx 32.391690,44.341590)

1. is the search result - I can't read that
2. I had put a pin on that GPS coordinates before and the Text looks again different
3. that is the text "Borsippa Ziggurat" I would prefer to see in the search results (1) and in the Waypoint text (2) - unfortunately I noted that the PoI's are not consistently labeled Roman/Arabic, but also the other way around ...
   

Unfortunately I could not reproduce the cases where I had multiple results for a GPS search - but I'll keep my eyes open for that.

Oh and you can't always search for like "Borsippa Ziggurat" because names are often written completely different or even the name in MRA might be a different one. I switched to GPS coordinate because of this in the first place....

[Robert Laudensack]

@Nick-Carthew thanks - I had "discovered" the coordinate button while writing this thread, but it is actually not the solution as the problem is a different one (than what I had suspected initially), yes I used slightly off GPS coordinates, but the issue is the Arabic texts in the end - see my other reply.