The route is planned to go the wrong way round the roundabout
-
Whilst planning a short route for a test, I was surprised to find that MRA Route Planner had routed the journey through a roundabout in the wrong direction.
The routing engine was set to the default (OSM).As soon as I switched the routing engine to HERE, the route was planned to go through the roundabout in the correct direction.
If I switch the calculation engine back to Standard (OSM) – and open the route in MRA Navigation – the route is initially displayed going the wrong way round the roundabout again. When I then start navigation, the route is displayed going the right way round the roundabout. However, you can still see the white line of the original route, which continues to go the wrong way round the roundabout.
Is this an OSM map error?
https://www.myrouteapp.com/de/social/route/13112788?mode=share
-
Yes, it’s a mapping error.
Especially if it’s just this roundabout.When starting navigation is clearly sees it’s not permitted and sends you round the other way.
-
Yes, it’s a mapping error.
Especially if it’s just this roundabout.When starting navigation is clearly sees it’s not permitted and sends you round the other way.
@Guzzist Yes a mapping error, it is the same on the Openstreetmap site
There was no indication on the roundabout that it should be one-way
The one-way has been added
It will take a while to propogate to the live Openstreetmap site & a fair while before it appears on MRA -
thank you all, I will report to OSM
-
@Corjan-Meijerink I'm sorry, but I found again a strange situation with a roundabout. Now, I dont believe any longer it's a map issue.
Could it be, it is related to the selected App language? I'm driving in Germany, but I selected English as App language. Could this be a reason?
Please could you explain: if - let me easily say - you should turn left, but it's a roundabout (with 4 exits). By which rule/setting, the routing algorithm is announcing:- leave roundabout on 3rd exit (in Germany)
- leave roundabout on 1st exit (in Great Britain)
Please see the route, which is following the roundabout in the correct way for Germany.
The see Instruction Icon in top left corner, which is showing strange instruction.
Nothing is impossible ;-)
In past: GARMIN Zumo 210->GARMIN Zumo 395->GARMIN XT=> now: DMD T865-X + MyRoute-App, LocusMaps, OsmAnd.
In past: GARMIN MapSource ->GARMIN BaseCamp->Tyre->Kurviger->Calimoto=> now: MRA-Routplanner. -
@Corjan-Meijerink I'm sorry, but I found again a strange situation with a roundabout. Now, I dont believe any longer it's a map issue.
Could it be, it is related to the selected App language? I'm driving in Germany, but I selected English as App language. Could this be a reason?
Please could you explain: if - let me easily say - you should turn left, but it's a roundabout (with 4 exits). By which rule/setting, the routing algorithm is announcing:- leave roundabout on 3rd exit (in Germany)
- leave roundabout on 1st exit (in Great Britain)
Please see the route, which is following the roundabout in the correct way for Germany.
The see Instruction Icon in top left corner, which is showing strange instruction.
@Guzzist language is definitely not influencing this. If this is a consistent issue, then something is definitely wrong. If it’s just this roundabout, a map error still makes most sense
-
@Corjan-Meijerink I'm sorry, but I found again a strange situation with a roundabout. Now, I dont believe any longer it's a map issue.
Could it be, it is related to the selected App language? I'm driving in Germany, but I selected English as App language. Could this be a reason?
Please could you explain: if - let me easily say - you should turn left, but it's a roundabout (with 4 exits). By which rule/setting, the routing algorithm is announcing:- leave roundabout on 3rd exit (in Germany)
- leave roundabout on 1st exit (in Great Britain)
Please see the route, which is following the roundabout in the correct way for Germany.
The see Instruction Icon in top left corner, which is showing strange instruction.
@Guzzist I would say most definitely not a language error, with MRA I ride 75% of my time in Europe on the wrong side of the road with the language set to english, it is never a problem
The path (blue line) is going in the correct direction so I do not think it is a map error
I have checked & there appears to be no map or navigation errors with the map data on the Here & OSM map sitesIf I try to simulate the path I have no such problem
From memory I think last year or the year before there was a problem I believe where all roundabouts were indicating to take the 1st exit.
I think what you have here is a just a glitch & the roundabout indicator has defaulted to the first option which is the 1st exit
Or maybe the fix a year ago was not perfect & sometimes it still appears
